Day centres for severe mental illness

Catty JS, Burns T, Comas A, Poole Z

Published Online:

July 16, 2008

The last 30 years have seen a large increase in the number of people with severe mental illness receiving treatment whilst living at home. Community care of the severely mentally ill is frequently enhanced by care provided by day centres run by non-medical services (Social Services in the UK, or the charitable sector). In this review we sought, but could not find, any evidence from well-conducted randomised trials of the effects of non-medical day centres. Day centres are currently becoming prominent in service planning, but this is not based on good evidence as to their effectiveness for people suffering from severe mental illness. If a choice between facilities is available, people with serious mental illnesses and their carers are currently left to make their own judgements based on the evidence of experience and a few non-randomised studies.

Abstract (click to read)

Background:

The number of people with severe mental illness who receive treatment whilst living at home has increased greatly over the last 30 years. Day centres and day hospitals frequently supplement this treatment.

Objectives:

To determine the effects of non-medical day centre care for people with severe mental illness.

Search strategy:

We updated our search in September 2005. All databases and searches are detailed in the body of the text.

Selection criteria:

We would have included all randomised controlled trials where seriously mentally ill people were allocated to non-medical day centre care.

Data collection and analysis:

We reliably selected studies, quality rated them and extracted data. For dichotomous data, it had been hoped to estimate the fixed effects Relative Risk (OR) with 95% confidence intervals (CI) and the number needed to treat statistic (NNT). Analysis was to have been by intention-to-treat. Normal continuous data were to have been summated using the weighted mean difference (WMD) and scale data presented only for those tools that had attained pre-specified levels of quality.

Main results:

Electronic searches identified over 300 citations but none were relevant to this review. We found no trials of non-medical day centres.

Authors' conclusions:

We feel that the inclusion of any studies less rigorous than randomised trials would result in misleading findings and that it is not unreasonable to expect well designed, conducted and reported randomised controlled trials of day centre care. More precise nomenclature would greatly help identify relevant work. At present non-randomised comparative studies give conflicting messages about the roles provided by day centres and the clinical and social needs they are able to meet. It is therefore probably best that people with serious mental illness and their carers, if given the choice, take a pragmatic decision on which type of unit best meets their needs. There is a clear need for randomised controlled trials of day centre care compared to other forms of day care, and when resources are limited, day centre care within the context of a pragmatic randomised trial may be the only way of ensuring equity of provision.

This record should be cited as:

Catty JS, Burns T, Comas A, Poole Z. Day centres for severe mental illness. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2007, Issue 1. Art. No.: CD001710. DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD001710.pub2

Assessed as up to date:

November 14, 2006

Find the research

Get full text at The Cochrane Library

Primary Review Group:

Schizophrenia Group

Health topics:

Effective practice/health systems > Reviews of interventions to improve specific types of practice > General management of a problem

Mental health > Schizophrenia & psychosis > Care package/setting of care

Mental health > Effective practice/health systems

Cochrane Summaries^beta

Independent high-quality evidence for health care decision making

Day centres for severe mental illness

More like this

Copyright © 2011 - The Cochrane Collaboration